Implementation Failures Are Threatening Our Plans To End The TB Epidemic

09/08/2016 12:17 PM IST | Updated 11/08/2016 8:31 AM IST
AFP/Getty Images

Co-authored by Zelalem Temesgen*

It is a matter of great tragedy that tuberculosis (TB), despite being a curable infectious disease, continues to kill over 1.5 million people every year. Nearly 9.5 million new cases of TB occur worldwide every year. Of these, nearly 3 million TB patients are considered "missing" -- they are either not diagnosed, or not reported to TB control programs.

In 2014, according to the WHO, about 80% of reported TB cases occurred in 22 countries. The six countries that stood out as having the largest number of incident cases in 2014 were India, Indonesia, Nigeria, Pakistan, People's Republic of China and South Africa.

Good technologies and interventions need to be effectively implemented for impact to be seen.

In 2014, India alone accounted for nearly 25% of the 9.5 million global TB cases. India also accounted for a third of the three million missing TB cases. TB is a major cause of deaths in India, and the emergence of severe forms of drug-resistant TB in urban areas such as Mumbai is another indication that the TB problem is not under control. There are several likely reasons for India's persistent TB problem, including social determinants and co-morbidities that fuel the TB epidemic, under-investment by the government, weak programme implementation, suboptimal quality of care in the private sector, and insufficient advocacy around TB.

In contrast to India, the TB epidemic in sub-Saharan Africa is characterized by high prevalence of HIV and TB co-infection, and a major problem with multidrug-resistant TB (MDR-TB) in countries such as South Africa, which also has the largest number of people living with HIV. The combination of HIV and TB poses immense challenges for TB control in Africa, as both infections work synergistically to kill and maim.

As we have previously advocated, to curb the TB epidemic, we will need to reach the missing TB patients, diagnose TB without long delays, and make sure they take the full course of anti-TB therapy. Only then will they stop transmitting the infection to those around them. We also need to make sure all TB-HIV co-infected patients have access to live-saving anti-retroviral drugs, and interventions of proven value (e.g. preventive therapy for latent TB infection, cotrimoxazole prophylaxis).

Reaching all the missing patients and ensuring appropriate TB treatment will require doctors and TB control programs to adopt and scale-up the best tools we have today, and modernize TB care. Compared to the situation even a decade ago, we have witnessed big changes in the TB technology landscape. We now have tools such as Xpert MTB/RIF that can rapidly and accurately detect TB, including drug-resistance. With more laboratories offering such rapid tests, there has been a substantial increase in the number of multidrug-resistant (MDR) cases detected.

Proven interventions such as daily, fixed dose combinations (FDCs) are not routinely used in all countries.

On the new drug front, bedaquiline and delamanid are already on the market in some countries. In addition, trials are underway to evaluate the efficacy of a new TB regimens such as PaMZ (which contains pretomanid, moxifloxacin, and pyrazinamide), BPaZ (bedaquiline, pretomanid, and pyrazinamide), and NIX regimen (bedaquiline, pretomanid, and linezolid). If these trials succeed, then TB patients might get new, shorter treatments within the next five years.

While the product landscape is looking promising, what is worrisome is the implementation gap.A recent report called "Out of Step" by MSF and Stop TB Partnership surveyed 24 high TB burden countries, to see how already existing TB policies and interventions are being implemented. This survey found major implementation gaps. For example, only eight countries surveyed had revised their national policies to include Xpert MTB/RIF as the initial diagnostic test for all adults and children with presumptive TB, replacing smear microscopy. Six countries still recommended intermittent treatment for drug-sensitive TB. Proven interventions such as daily, fixed dose combinations (FDCs) are not routinely used in all countries. Furthermore, most high-burden countries are still using antiquated diagnostics with limited accuracy.

Other studies have shown similar implementation failures. For example, even though South Africa has scaled-up rapid molecular testing, there are data showing long gaps between sample collection and initiation of TB treatment. Empirical TB management is widespread, even with Xpert roll-out, and health system weaknesses have blunted the impact of new diagnostics. In South Africa, only about half of all patients with TB and HIV are on anti-retroviral therapy, and only about 50% of TB patients with MDR are on second-line therapy. These gaps in the TB/HIV treatment cascade underscore the need for better program management.

In India, an average TB patient is diagnosed after a delay of nearly 2 months, and after seeing 3 providers. At the primary care level, TB testing is rare, even among those with classic TB symptoms, and most patients are managed with repeated cycles of empirical broad-spectrum antibiotic therapies.

It is time for doctors, hospitals, and healthcare programs to embrace and scale up new TB technologies and address implementation gaps...

Indian studies also show major gaps in TB knowledge and self-reported practices of providers, suggesting poor adherence to established standards in the private sector. A recent study, using simulated patients, confirmed the overall low quality of TB care in the private sector, and revealed a substantial gap between what doctors know and what they actually do in their practice. India's public sector is still heavily reliant on insensitive sputum smears, and most patients do not get tested for drug-resistance. India is yet to make daily FDCs widely available to all patients. In fact, Treatment Action Group and civil society partners have just launched a campaign called #BrokenTBPromises to remind the Indian government about the need to address implementation failures.

These issues reinforce the message that technologies alone are never enough. Good technologies and interventions need to be effectively implemented for impact to be seen. High-burden countries will need to improve the efficiency of their healthcare delivery systems, ensure better uptake of new technologies, and achieve greater linkages across the TB and HIV care continuum. While we wait for next-generation technologies, national TB programs must scale-up the current best diagnostics. While we wait for shorter drug regimens, doctors and programs can improve the effectiveness of existing treatments by improving treatment adherence.

In summary, it is time for doctors, hospitals, and healthcare programs to embrace and scale up new TB technologies and address implementation gaps to make sure TB patients get the best care that they deserve. Indeed, TB patients, doctors, civil society, and stakeholders should have low tolerance for major implementation gaps. In a widely acclaimed speech delivered recently at the Durban TB and AIDS conferences, Mr. Stephen Lewis, a former UN Special Envoy for HIV/AIDS, argued for the need to make countries accountable for serious implementation gaps in TB and HIV care. He said that "it's absolutely necessary to name and shame countries, openly, unapologetically, when their political fraudulence puts their own citizens at risk."

* Prof Zelalem Temesgen MD FIDSA AAHIVS is Professor of Medicine, Director of the HIV Program at Mayo Clinic, and Executive Director of the Mayo Clinic Center for Tuberculosis. He has previously served as a member of the United States President's Advisory Council in HIV and as a member of the Scientific Advisory Committee for the United States President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR).

Rio Olympics -- India

More On This Topic