Yakub Memon Case: Hope Fades For Death Row Convict As SC Order, Mercy Plea Disposed Adversely

29/07/2015 4:02 PM IST | Updated 15/07/2016 8:25 AM IST
NEW! HIGHLIGHT AND SHARE
Highlight text to share via Facebook and Twitter
MONEY SHARMA via Getty Images
Indian protesters shout slogans during a protest against the death sentence of convicted bomb plotter Yakub Memon, a key plotter of the bomb attacks which killed hundreds in Mumbai in 1993, in New Delhi on July 27, 2015. India's top court on July 21, 2015 rejected a final appeal by Memon, a key plotter of bomb attacks that killed hundreds in Mumbai in 1993, paving the way for his execution. AFP PHOTO / MONEY SHARMA (Photo credit should read MONEY SHARMA/AFP/Getty Images)

NEW DELHI -- Yakub Memon, convicted in the 1993 Mumbai blasts case, has exhausted nearly all legal avenues before him as a Supreme Court bench today ruled against both arguments which his team of lawyers had advanced. The Maharashtra Governor CH Vidyasagar Rao has also turned down his mercy petition.

Now only a mercy petition before President Pranab Mukherjee, filed Wednesday morning, remains to be disposed.

The Supreme Court decided against Memon's team's argument that there were procedural lapses in the way his curative petition was heard, and also in the manner in which his death warrant was issued while his curative petition was pending before the apex court.

On Wednesday, Public Prosecutor Ujjwal Nikam said the apex court had ruled that due process was followed in the issuance of Memon's death warrant on April 30, but the death sentence scheduled for Thursday morning will only be carried out subject to the decision taken by President Pranab Mukherjee on the pending mercy plea.

"There is no legal impediment in the execution of the death warrant," said Nikam.

A larger bench of the Supreme Court heard the case today after a two-member bench was divided on the matter on Tuesday.

The case has deeply polarised opinion after it has become increasingly clear that Memon cooperated with Indian intelligence agencies to return with family from Karachi, where they were under the protection of the Inter Services Intelligence, Pakistan's intelligence agency.

The highly respected Indian intelligence official B. Raman has written a piece confirming Yakub's cooperation, highlighting the fact that he had brought evidence which helped India prove Pakistan's involvement in the event, which was published in the news outlet Rediff.com recently.

This resulted in a petition by eminent citizens, including several former Supreme Court judges, to President Pranab Mukherjee asking for commuting Memon's death sentence.

READ: Owaisi Says Memon Is Being Hanged Because Of His Religion

READ: SC Divided Over Yakub Memon's Plea, Refers It To CJI

yakub memon

Memon's lawyer Raju Ramachandran told the apex court that the TADA court issued a death warrant on April 30 while his curative petition was pending, and he was not given an opportunity to explain whether he had exhausted all legal remedies.

Ramachandran has also argued that while the death of warrant was issued on April 30, Memon was only told about the date of his execution on July 13.

The Maharashtra government told the court that Memon has exhausted all legal remedies, and the death sentence should be carried out as a deterrent for those who plot terror attacks against India. The government has also emphasised the need to provide closure to the families of 257 victims, who have waited 22 years for justice.

On Wednesday, Memon filed a fresh mercy petition with President Pranab Mukherjee.

Attorney general Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for the Maharashtra government, has argued that Memon should not be allowed to file a series of petitions, and the matter should be closed.

On Tuesday, the two-judge bench of Justice A.R. Dave and Justice Kurian Joseph delivered a split verdict on Memon's plea, seeking stay of his execution on July 30, and referred the matter to the Chief Justice of India.

If his mercy pleas are turned down, Memon's death sentence will be the first execution in connection with the 1993 serial blasts.

Memon, a chartered accountant, is the younger brother of Ibrahim Memon, also known as Tiger Memon, the prime accused in the case, who is absconding. During the course of the investigation, it was revealed that it was Tiger who got Yakub involved in the deadly attack on Mumbai.

While being convicted of a conspiracy to commit the terrorist attack, the 53-year-old has argued that he was never actually involved in executing the serial bomb blasts on March 12, 1993.

READ: Full Text Of Petition By Eminent Citizens Pleading Presidential Pardon For Yakub Memon

yakub memon

Several eminent Indians, including film makers, activists and politicians, have petitioned President Mukherjee to stay Memon's execution citing procedural lapses and "disturbing aspects of this case which make the award of death sentence of Yakub Memon as grossly unfair, arbitrary and excessive."

In a letter to Mukherjee, they wrote that Tiger Memon and Dawood Ibrahim are the main conspirators in the case.

"Both Tiger Memon and Dawood Ibrahim have been absconding and Yakub, brother of Tiger Memon, who was not the main actor in the conspiracy is being executed," they wrote.

Excerpts from the letter to the President

Yakub Memon was not given advance notice of the death warrant hearing and as a result of which he and his lawyers could not participate and contest the issuance of the death warrant.

As per the case of the prosecution, the 1993 bomb blasts were orchestrated by Tiger Memon and Dawood Ibrahim to seek revenge for the demolition of Babri Masjid in Ayodhya(YakubMemon v. State of Maharashtra, (2013) 13 SCC 1 para 148, 1253). Both Tiger Memon and Dawood Ibrahim have been absconding and Yakub, brother of Tiger Memon, who was not the main actor in the conspiracy is being executed.

The TADA Court convicted 100 persons and awarded death penalty to 11 persons. In appeal, the Supreme Court commuted the death sentences of all the convicts except Yakub Memon. In comparison to Yakub Memon, the 10 co-accused persons whose death sentences were commuted planted the bombs themselves and played a much more critical and direct role in the actual execution of the bomb blast conspiracy. Several of whom even travelled to Pakistan for arms training. This shows Yakub Abdul Razak Memon who is facing an imminent execution only on account of being Tiger Memon's younger brother.

Meanwhile, the Supreme Court today dismissed the central government's curative petition, and confirmed its ruling of commuting the death sentence to life imprisonment of three persons - Santhan, Murugan and Perarivalan - convicted of killing former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi.

Like Us On Facebook |
Follow Us On Twitter |
Contact HuffPost India

More On This Topic